Disability Architecture: Ar. Jaime Silva on the Push for Accessible Spaces

July 22, 2024
|
By 
Elle Yap

How are we thinking about disability architecture in today’s world? For architect Jaime Silva, the process of creating more accessible buildings is a constant effort to pursue the proper accommodations for persons with disabilities (PWD).

BluPrint sat down with the architect to discuss his advocacy for disability rights in the country. This discussion included his involvement with the Philippine Foundation for the Rehabilitation of the Disabled (PFRD), as well as a rundown of the evolution of accessibility measures in the country. 

The Influence of the Apolinario Mabini Awards

During the conversation, Jaime Silva discussed the efforts of PWD groups to improve and enlighten corporations on how to make their buildings more accessible. 

Silva, who is visually-impaired, said he got involved with PFRD in 2002 after he himself won an Apolinario Mabini Award. They invited him to become part of the selection committee. His involvement came after the organization desired to award more buildings and property managers for their commitment to accessibility. 

Early on, around five buildings were chosen for the award. Most of the winners for the early years were malls, Silva said, “kasi malls had more the budget, eh? And they’re really public […] buildings.”

SM City Grand Central, which won the Gold tier of the Apolinario Mabini Awards in 2023. Photo by SuperFranztendo 64. Source: Wikimedia Commons.
SM City Grand Central which won the Gold tier of the Apolinario Mabini Awards in 2023 Photo by SuperFranztendo 64 Source Wikimedia Commons

Over the past two decades, competition for the awards from major property developers like SM and Ayala pushed forward the cause of accessibility in the country. Their nomination pool for compliant buildings has grown from eleven in 2005 to over 300 in 2023. 

The eagerness for the award also pushed other developers to vie for the accessibility award by renovating their buildings to fit the criteria better. They’ve worked with developers such as Robinsons and Filinvest to modify their structures accordingly.

Silva warns, however, that such adjustments take years to work through. It boils down to the specifications needed to make it safe for PWDs. For example, one needs a certain slope, distance, and gradient for wheelchair ramps to work properly and safely. 

“We tried, of course, but it will take a while, eh. Because these are infrastructures, and if not done correctly, it will need a [bigger] budget to correct them, to rectify,” he said. “But what is important is they are aware.”

The Evolution of Disability Laws

Jaime Silva also works as a sub-chair for the National Council on Disability Affairs’ subcommittee on accessibility and transportation. He said that he and other disability advocates recently worked to update the current implementing rules and regulations (IRR) of Batas Pambansa 344. 

The updates included different additions for the mentally-disabled, the blind, the deaf, and so on. These came about because he said that the original law focused more on ambulatory disabilities, ignoring the needs of other PWDs. 

A person with visual-impairment using braille and tactile flooring to locate an elevator. Photo by John Robert McPherson. Source: Wikimedia Commons.
A person with visual impairment using braille and tactile flooring to locate an elevator Photo by John Robert McPherson Source Wikimedia Commons

Some of the new updates push for braille on elevators, including on the doors itself to help the blind know what floor they are on. There’s also a push for bathrooms to have enough space for wheelchair users to be able to navigate inside it alone. Tactile floor surfaces—hard lines and circles on the floor creating a guiding path for the blind—also becomes a requirement in different transportation hubs. 

An example of tactile flooring as used in disability architecture. Photo by BceMckenz Marks. Source: Wikimedia Commons.
An example of tactile flooring as used in disability architecture Photo by BceMckenz Marks Source Wikimedia Commons

Crafting Reforms in the IRR

These ideas were proposed in early 2013. Delays in the implementation took close to a decade, largely due to trying to ensure that the new rules still fell within the purview of the original law. The current update allowed for the rules to be reviewed and modified every two years, allowing for new studies to be incorporated into the laws. 

“Nilagay namin ng provision that this has to be revisited every two years,” he said. “Kasi baka may mga changes. Baka there are some provisions that we did that [makes it] more difficult for persons with disabilities to use. So we can always revise that, you know. Or if there are things that we missed, pwede na namin, insert, isingit, you know. 

“So, basically, it will continue to be like that. We implement, and then if there are some changes, then we revisit, and then come up with changes, and disseminate again.”

The Slow Charge of Progress

The continued push for accessibility has not always been steady. Much of it comes from a lack of political will and support from those in power. 

For example, then-President Rodrigo Duterte refused to allow PFRD to hold the 2017 Apolinario Mabini awarding at the Heroes Hall function area in Malacañang Palace. This forced them to seek new accommodations for that year despite the tradition of the awarding being set there. Silva said that they only do the awarding in non-election years to ensure the support of the people in office. 

He also calls out the need for inclusive schools, blaming much of the shoddy architecture to them being rushed out by local government officials looking for easy recognition. 

A high school in Cebu. Photo by PaulGorduiz106. Source: Wikimedia Commons.
A high school in Cebu Photo by PaulGorduiz106 Source Wikimedia Commons

“Ang problem kasi sa school: sometimes these are donated by the mayor, he said. “So yung building official, dictado siya ni mayor, pinaspasan, tapos hindi naman that accessible. Tapos yung facility engineers ng DepEd, pinapapirma na agad si principal para magamit na niya yung school na ginawa, which is not really that accessible. Pero si principal, walang namang alam sa technical, pipirma siya, kasi kailangan.

“At the end of the day, nandoon ang school, pero hindi siya accessible, kaya yung mga naka-wheelchair nahihirapan.”

Pushing Architects Towards Accessible Spaces

An example of a floor plan which lacks dimensions for the rooms. Photo by Emil Presuhn. Source: Wikimedia Commons.
An example of a floor plan which lacks dimensions for the rooms Photo by Emil Presuhn Source Wikimedia Commons

Part of the slow charge for progress also comes from some architects not seeing its importance in buildings. One of the new rules pushes for accessibility sheets with specific dimensions instead of just the basic floor plans. The specificity in these areas allow contractors to better visualize the ramps, bathrooms, and other spaces in a PWD-friendly way. 

He illustrates this problem with an excursion he ended up doing in the Barangay San Lorenzo, Makati where he checked the buildings there for compliance to BP 344. Despite being built after 2000, he said that most of the buildings were not compliant to the law. 

“I’ve been voicing it out with the NCDA, the Council on Human Rights, the DPWH, that we should have an accessibility sheet,” he said.

Pushing Forward a Equal Future for All

Jaime Silva emphasized how architecture has changed to accommodate PWDs in the country. Even with blunders such as the recent wheelchair ramp made for the EDSA busway, spaces across the country continue to improve slowly towards accessibility. 

“These are new developments we are seeing,” he said. “Because these developers, they also want to make their facilities accessible. And because of this law, because of the recognitions we are giving, they also want [to be more accessible].”

Accessible wheelchair ramp for train in Tokyo. An example of disability architecture at work. Photo by Nesnad. Source: Wikimedia Commons.
Accessible wheelchair ramp for train in Tokyo An example of disability architecture at work Photo by Nesnad Source Wikimedia Commons

The NCDA, PFRD, and other organizations also work to ensure that PWDs are trained and empowered to participate in the betterment of society in general. 

“At least there’s some movement,” he said. “That somebody is focused on this and working on this.”

How we accommodate the marginalized members of our community shows our values as a society. The progress of disability architecture in our country, slow as it may be, predicts a better future where society values people as people, regardless of wealth or status or influence. PWDs deserve a place in our country where they can live with dignity and respect. 

Related reading: Banksy Universe Was Never Pre-Approved

Beet: The Fall Color Trend You Need to Know About.

Beet: The Fall Color Trend You Need to Know About

There’s no denying that fall is synonymous with warm colors. Reds, oranges, yellows, browns, and purples reflect the vibrant tones of fallen leaves that typically make up this season’s palette. At home, these classic shades bring a cozy and inviting atmosphere whether used in small or large accents. However, a surprising and less traditional hue […]

Pueblo de Oro Townsquare Fuses Tradition and Modernity.

Pueblo de Oro Townsquare Fuses Tradition and Modernity

Nestled on the picturesque shores of Mactan Island, Cebu, Pueblo de Oro Townsquare stands as a testament to innovative architectural design. The project, designed by Barchan + Architecture, seamlessly blends local cultural elements with modern functionality. It exemplifies a harmonious convergence of community needs, sustainable practices, and aesthetic appeal. In an interview with Jason Buensalido, […]

Three paintings for Nunzio Paci's "Eyes Closed." Photo by Elle Yap.

‘Eyes Closed’: Nunzio Paci Dissects Humanity and Nature’s Relationship

Eyes Closed, the newest exhibit at Galerie Stephanie, finds the balance between realism and fantasy in the paintings featured. Italian artist Nunzio Paci revels in capturing the middle ground of life and death, creating something both haunting and calming in the process.  Paci works with the idea of portraying life as dreamlike and intangible. It […]

"Zóbel: The Future of the Past" Celebrates Fernando Zóbel's Centennial.

“Zóbel: The Future of the Past” Celebrates Fernando Zóbel’s Centennial

Ayala Museum proudly hosted the Asian premiere of “Zóbel: The Future of the Past” on September 14, 2024. First showcased at Spain’s Museo Nacional del Prado in 2022, this comprehensive exhibition is a tribute to Fernando Zóbel. The renowned artist and art critic played a pivotal role in shaping both Philippine and global art history.  […]

The Cabangis' Family's new exhibit at Modeka Art, "Homemade." Photo by Elle Yap.

Cabangis Family Joins Forces for Collaborative Exhibit in Modeka Art

Homemade puts together four of the members of the Cabangis family in their first group exhibit. The Modeka Art show, open until September 28, gives the artists a great opportunity to display their art together as a way of exploring their present works in relation to each other.  The patriarch Benjie Cabangis, and his three […]

Yushoken: Crafting Atmosphere Through Architectural Narrative.

Yushoken: Crafting Atmosphere Through Architectural Narrative

Through materiality, a structure can express its values and personality. CEO and Founder of Nippon Hasha group of companies, Ryan Cruz, acknowledges that each of his brands have a distinct personality in which he wishes to express in the dining experience. Restaurants such as Kazunori, Mendokoro, Yushoken and Marudori each have a level of distinction […]

Download this month's BLUPRINT magazine digital copy from:
Subscribe via [email protected]