Advertisement

The Dahmer series, Ann Rule books, and the Suspect podcast. If you’re a true crime fan, these are only a few ways to feed your serial killer fetish. But would you dare to go as far as collecting real crime memorabilia? While it’s been around for a while, the industry of buying and selling murder-related objects remains controversial. Intrigued by the dark and unusual? Let’s delve into the world of decorating with items inspired by true crime.

Murderabilia and its Origins

Murderabilia and The Case of Decorating with Murder Objects.
Charles Manson’s murder weapon. Photo from Flickr.

Coined by director and crime victim advocate Andy Kahan, murderabilia is any item associated with murderers or murder cases. It can be mugshots, vehicles, artworks, handwritten letters, clothes, hair strands, or any personal items connected to a crime scene. 

The dark market of murderabilia is thought to begin in the late 1990s when Serial Killer Ink’s owner Eric Holler revealed selling crime items on eBay in 1997. He regarded collecting murderabilia as a “money-making business” and “a walk on the edge” of our inner darkness. 

But according to Kahan, people have collected murderabilia since the primitive age. Such a long history we’re subconsciously unaware of explains why the interest remains even when it seems creepy and unlawful. 

The Controversy of Murderabilia

Murderabilia and The Case of Decorating with Murder Objects.
John Wayne Gacy’s Pogo the Clown Painting. Photo from Pinterest.

Collecting true crime-related pieces isn’t a crime. But ever since murderabilia became a way for personal profit, it gained a negative connotation in the public’s view. 

Kahan explained that people are free to collect any item they want. But he draws the line when the act becomes an exploitation of crime stories. Selling items like John Wayne Gacy paintings at an incredibly high price is where murderabilia loses its historical sense. Despite its questionable artistic merit compared to other meticulously-made artworks, the murderer’s paintings still receive a high regard simply because of its mainstream story. Instead of seeing them as memorabilia of the tragedy, these items become more of a trophy that people collect out of pride.

While expensive crime objects in online shops and auctions are still in demand, it doesn’t mean the real sense of collecting murderabilia is dead. Most pricey crime items are those related to serial killer stories popularized by the mainstream media. So, for true crime enthusiasts, you don’t have to be a victim of this system to get murderabilia.

Evidence of Reasons

Murderabilia and The Case of Decorating with Murder Objects.

Apart from making a fortune, the reasons for collecting murderabilia is a spectrum, exploring psychological, social, and cultural aspects. 

To seek thrill. Some find pleasure in collecting and consider it as an enjoyable way of connecting with the context of the crime. Owning murderabilia allows them to somehow experience an authentic connection to the crime story. It additionally gives a sense of satisfaction, particularly if the collector is knowledgeable of the tragedy.

To treasure historical artifacts. Like other collectors, people see murderabilia as tangible reminders of heinous events. Even if they are a part of tragedies, collecting preserves the evidence of their dark history. 

To use as lucky charms. Influenced by interconnected cultures, carrying lucky charms is a common attachment of sentimental and religious values. And as crime stories leave emotional impact, people also seek protection from murderabilia as a way to repel or control this energy.

Guilty or Not Guilty

Murderabilia and The Case of Decorating with Murder Objects.
Jeffrey Dahmer’s Handprint. Photo from Flickr.

Murderabilia has been banned from eBay since 2001—and it’s one thing to consider when deciding to  put them in your home. Because of their association with criminal acts, the ethical value of these items can be questionable. 

It’s important to know who will benefit when you buy these items. When the media publicizes murder cases, killers sometimes gain profits by publishing their stories or turning them into bio-flicks. And there is a probability that collecting murderabilia will encourage similar crimes. So to ensure a clean conscience, first check the seller’s background. If it’s not for a charity or for the good of the crime victims, then it’s best not to make the purchase.

It’s also crucial to ask about the story of the crime item and how it reflects your morality. True crime collectors refuse to gather items related to pedophiles or cases with children victims. It all boils down to your perception and ethical leanings when it comes to collecting these sensitive objects. 

It’s not a sin to get drawn into crime stories. As thinking beings driven by morals and free will, murderabilia could be a way to develop empathy by practicing your judgment on debatable things. Now that you uncovered the case of murderabilia, would you decorate your house with them?

Read more: Rich and Rare: Art Lovers Share Advice for Collectors

Sketching Modernity 04: The DBP Building

The DBP Building as a Landmark of the International Style At the corner of Sen. Gil Puyat Avenue and Makati Avenue stands a landmark of the Makati Central Business District. It is one of the last still standing that were built in the first wave of construction in district fifty years ago. The Development Bank […]

Anthology Expands the Conversation Around Philippine Architecture

“Buildings only become architectureArchitectureThe art and science of designing and constructing buildings, structures, and spaces that are functional, safe, and aesthetically pleasing. It encompasses the planning, design, materials, and techniques used to createGo to Architecture Glossary when they are shared,” said William Ti Jr., founder of the Anthology Festival and WTA Architecture and Design Studio, […]

Sketching Modernity 03: Asian Institute of Management

A Filipino Interpretation of Modernist Architecture Unlike the rest of Makati today, the northern end of Paseo de Roxas in Makati is anchored by a low complex rather than a tall skyscraper. This is the elegant Asian Institute of Management, designed by architect Gabriel Formoso and completed in 1971. In my opinion, the building is […]

Philippine Interior Design Claims Its Place in Southeast Asia

“Thailand has claimed urban creativity and livability. Singapore has institutional design leadership. Indonesia is emerging as a design hub. Vietnam is moving into design innovation. And the Philippines? Its position is not weak. It is simply unclaimed.” For IDr. Cecil Ravelas, National President of the Philippine Institute of Interior Designers (PIID), the challenge is not […]

Sketching Modernity 02: Ramon Magsaysay Center

The Ramon Magsaysay Center as a Modernist Landmark Driving down Roxas boulevard from Rizal Park, what will catch your eye is the most elegant modernist structure in the country, the Ramon Magsaysay Center. Most established Filipino architects put it in their top ten lists of favorite buildings. It was designed by Alfredo J. Luz, who […]

Maker’s Mark: Rinna Soriano on the Discipline of Making

Rinna Soriano’s favorite part of her work is sanding. At her workbench, she stays focused, following the grain, adjusting to changes in its direction. NarraNarraThe national tree of the Philippines, Pterocarpus indicus, prized for its durable, reddish-gold hardwood and handsome grain. Traditionally used for furniture, flooring, and carved panels, narra is now protected fromGo to […]

Hannah Haber

Contributor
Read the issues.
Collect the volumes.

Recommended Video

Tap to Unmute
Unmute
0:00
0:00 / 0:00
0:00

To provide a customized ad experience, we need to know if you are of legal age in your region.

By making a selection, you agree to our Terms & Conditions.