The Manila’Bang Show 2024 happened between November 14 to 17 at SPACE at OneAyala. The new venue gives artists and galleries an opportunity to showcase their art at the heart of the Makati Central Business District. With that in mind, BluPrint takes you on the ground of its opening day. Many galleries came out in […]
Artists Pivot to Cara as Anti-AI Sentiment Grows Among Artists
One of the biggest news stories for social media in recent weeks is Cara, a social media platform specifically created for artists. Its uniqueness as a platform stems not from catering to artists, but its prohibition of AI-generated art on its platform. It comes as artists look for an alternative platform that share their anti-AI sentiments.
Founded by Singaporean photographer Zhang Jingna, the volunteer-run app provides artists with the ability to showcase their portfolios for public viewing. One can post photographs, videos, and even GIFs of their art. There’s also a jobs board for people looking for human artists to commission or employ.
What has attracted artists to the platform, however, is its anti-AI stance. The app contains a third-party filter that detects and rejects AI art. As an organization, none of the images posted are being used to train an AI, and scraping is forbidden. It also offers services that prevent artists’ works from being scraped for the use of artificial intelligence. A collaboration with Glaze allows artists to prevent machines from mimicking the artist’s works.
Scraping Information to Use in Datasets
For much of the past few years, platforms like Instagram and DeviantArt became the defacto place for artists to post and promote their works. However, the recent advent of generative AI images has turned this over its head.
DeviantArt has been flooded with AI art from bots as more and more of its creative community abandons the website. Moreover, artists sued the company over allegations that they used millions of images in the website to train DreamUp, the website’s AI image generator, without permission from the artists.
Meanwhile, Meta, Instagram’s parent company, announced that they will be training their in-house AI program with data from its social media sites. While creators can opt out of this for countries in the European Union, most countries’ users would need to make their posts private to keep itself out of the scraping.
That announcement, more than anything, instigated the migration of artists to Cara. Over 300,000 users downloaded the app in June 2024 so far. Its user base grew from 40,000 users to more than 650,000 almost overnight, causing the app to crash temporarily.
The Unethical Practice of AI Scraping
Artists push against image generative AI as anti-creativity due to how it tends to copy the works it trains on. Much of the datasets used on AI contain copyrighted images taken without consent of the artist.
Different practices show that copyrighted works and writing appear to be part of training datasets despite denials from AI tech companies. The DeviantArt case mentioned above found a smoking gun in the form of spreadsheets and screenshots from Midjourney allegedly showing artists whose works were used to train the AI.
On record, companies like OpenAI admitted that they need copyrighted works to train their artificial intelligence. When questioned regarding the matter, OpenAI, DeviantArt, Meta, and so on have argued that the use of the works fall under Fair Use.
The perception of artificial intelligence as anti-artist have been growing since its public introduction. OpenAI’s Chief Technology Officer Mira Murati cemented this perception recently. In a talk at Dartmouth University, Murati said that she believes that the creative jobs replaced by generative AI should not have been there in the first place.
“Some creative jobs maybe will go away, but maybe they shouldn’t have been there in the first place,” she said.
The Pedigree Behind Cara
As a company, Cara’s concern centers on the protection of the artist’s intellectual property, something which websites like DeviantArt and Instagram have failed to do.
“[While] generative AI can be a powerful tool, we cannot ignore that AI companies are using datasets trained on copyrighted work and private personal data without our consent,” the company said. “We understand that platforms may not have the power to solve the unethical and legal issues surrounding such datasets alone, but we believe that at the very least, they [should show] solidarity and respect for artists and their communities in such times.”
The app’s founder, Zhang Jingna, gives the project extra credibility due to her recent trials. She recently won an appeal, for example, against photographer Jeff Dieschburg, who plagiarized her work in a winning entry for Harper’s Bazaar Vietnam in 2017.
Beyond that, Zhang is a visible activist against unethical AI scraping. She and others sued Google for allegedly using copyrighted material to train their in-house image generator. She’s also a plaintiff for the aforementioned case against DeviantArt. While she’s not necessarily anti-AI, she has pushed back against corporations’ trampling on artist rights.
“There’s a nuance to how we see things, but I don’t think people understand that the art we do is not a product,” she told TechCrunch during an interview.
Related reading: How Is Artificial Intelligence Disrupting the World of Architecture?
There is no excerpt because this is a protected post.
Every year, the holiday season brings a flurry of new decor trends. While it’s fun to experiment with the latest styles, sometimes it can be a little taxing and confusing keeping up with them. But the good news is that you don’t need to follow every trend to create a stunning Yuletide aesthetic. Here are […]
The ICA Art Fair happened from November 21 to 23 at W High Street in Bonifacio Global City (BGC). This inaugural art fair was organized as a charity event for the benefit of the ICA Alumni Association Scholarship Foundation. “This one-of-a-kind charity event will feature a curated selection of leading contemporary artists, displaying works across […]
Swiss architect and designer Aurel Aebi, co-founder of atelier oï alongside Armand Louis and Patrick Reymond, brings a tactile, storytelling approach to design. Visiting Manila for the Louis Vuitton Savoir Rêver exhibition, Aebi shared insights into their philosophy and process, demonstrating how everyday objects can transform into elegant, functional art pieces. At atelier oï’s studio […]
This 2024, we’ve seen a lot of emerging design ideas, taking inspiration from fashion, music, psychology, and philosophy, that changed the way we perceive interior spaces. And now that we’re approaching the Yuletide season, you might want to break away from your usual way of decorating and try something fresh and out of the ordinary. […]
Download this month's BLUPRINT magazine digital copy from:
Subscribe via [email protected]